Goodreads is a website where you can list the books you read, leave your gradings/reviews, and do a bunch of other community-oriented things. It is, not surprisingly, owned by Amazon. Many people like to grade the books they read (from 1 to 5 stars), without leaving any review. I like to write reviews without grading books, for two reasons. First, I am not sure how a book should be graded (is it a measure of what I learned while reading it? Or of the sheer pleasure I had in finishing it? …). Second, I feel that reviews are a useful exercise of synthesis, as well as a good memo on my impression of the book.
However, Goodreads does not let you do that, probably because its machine learning algorithms are not sophisticated enough to profile you from the sheer text of reviews. So I also leave a grade, which is more or less an answer to the following question: “If the me after reading the book was to meet the me before reading the book, how likely is the former to recommend to the latter to read the book?”
Here are some of my reviews (without the grade). Those in English come first, then those in Italian.
Independent People by Halldór Laxness
A hidden gem. Between Thomas Mann and Zola, Laxness tells the story of the impossible rise and certain fall of a family in the Icelandic backcountry, whose pater familias is willing to sacrifice everything – his pride, any small luxury, even the life and love of his closest ones – to reach the middle-class status of independent peasant. In a remote, swampy valley cursed by stories of witches and devils, Bjartur builds his independent farm and fights restless for it through harsh times, and the seductive good times caused by the First World War that inflated Icelandic economy. The enthusiasm of those good times will eventually bring him to bankrupt, but not bend his will of being independent. The traditional epic poems are his only form of culture, and his natural mistrust towards anything that is too abstract – let it be religion, politics, or ideals of brotherhood among peasants – will make him a perfect victim for the sneaky politicians of the time.
Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad
Marlow tells his fellow sailors about his experience as the captain of a sailing boat going up the Congo river in colonial Africa. He was sent there by a European company hungry for ivory with the goal of finding the mysterious Mr Kurtz, head of one of the most important stations of the company, far into the jungle.
Marlow travels through a land tormented by the imperialists, that pays them back torturing them with illnesses and fear, and a society they cannot understand. He compares the European colonists with the Romans that first landed in England centuries before. About the latter, he says:
“All that mysterious life of the wilderness that stirs in the forest, in the jungles, in the hearts of wild men. There’s no initiation either into such mysteries. He has to live in the midst of the incomprehensible, which is also detestable. And it has fascination, too, that goes to work upon him. The fascination of the abomination – you know, imagine the growing regrets, the longing to escape, the powerless disgust, the surrender, the hate. ”
Mr Kurtz brings this mixture of horror and fascination to the extreme: worshipped like a God by the locals, and at the same time witness of many atrocities that led him to the edge of the madness. ‘The horror! The horror!’, he will cry to Marlow during one of his last deliriums.
Konrad wrote Heart of darkness in English, but this was not his mother language. So his style is quite far from those of classical English novels. The syntax is more complex, and there are few dialogues. Even though it is around 100 pages long, it feels it is a lot longer. I often had to read descriptions more than once in order to grasp them.
It is impossible to read and judge Heart of darkness without considering the influence it has had on collective imagination, especially (but not only) through its most popular child, Coppola’s Apocalypse now. His description of the entanglement between the fascination and the horror of the unknown has become archetypal ever since, and many other authors built a career on it, e.g. Lovecraft. As Lovecraft, Konrad makes you imagine, feel, fear the horror, but never really describes it. As Marlow says to his fellows sailors, talking about Kurtz:
“Do you seem him? Do you see the story? Do you see anything? It seems to me I am trying to tell you a dream – making a vain attempt, because no relation of a dream can convey the dream-sensation, that commingling of absurdity, surprise, and bewilderment in a tremor of struggling revolt, that notion of being captured by the incredible which is the very essence of dreams… No, it is impossible; it is impossible to convey the life-sensation of any given epoch of one’s existence – that which makes its truth, its meaning – its subtle and penetrating essence. It is impossible. We live, as we dream – alone…”
A must read.
Madame Bovary by Gustave Flaubert
Even if its size and style may be outdated, Madame Bovary is still a great read for the characters it depicts. They go far beyond from being just 19th century French peasants – they’re eternal, timeless examples of human beings.
The good, humble, simple-minded Charles Bovary, for whom life at its best is an eternal repetition of the same calm gestures. The self-centered, day-dreaming Emma Bovary, whose long for sensuality and cheap feelings is at the core of, and gives the name to, all the story. And Mr. Homais, who is probably the most interesting and political character. A pharmacist, that supports the “modern”, “illuministic” ideas from Voltaire in order to differentiate himself from the crowd and the other peasants. In reality, he is a perfect example of social climber, ready to neglect his humanitarian ideals for his own interests. Through him, I think Flaubert wants at the same time to attack his own times, and warn the readers against self-proclamed intellectuals and popular leaders.
Prater Violet by Christopher Isherwood
Isherwood depicts with irony and perceptiveness the various processes of film-making and the characters orbiting around a blockbuster. Hired to help an Austrian director writing the screenplay of a British movie, Isherwood shrinks his role to little more than an observer, and presents a roundup of hilarious characters: an exuberant producer, who is much smarter than he shows; a disillusioned technician with a fake leg, longing for a word ruled by technocrats; a sensitive secretary; most interesting of all, a volcanic and talented director, deeply in love with his art and politics, that addresses waitresses with quotes from Shakespeare and daily dictates poems to his secretary.
Set in the pre-war atmosphere of the 1930’s, the book also conveys the idleness of a period when Europe seemed to bury its head in the sand, not really doing anything to stop Hitler’s rise to power. As Bergmann – the director – shouts to a British journalist:
” I expect everybody to care (about the fact that an antidemocratic government took power in Austria)! Everybody who is not a coward, a moron, a piece of dirt. I expect this whole damned island (England) to care. I will tell you something: if they do not care, they will be made to care. The whole lot of you. You will be bombed and slaughtered and conquered. ”
Roughly a hundred pages long, Isherwood’s novel does not delve deeply into the characters – most of them are brought to the attention of the reader for a few pages, and then quickly go back to the background. And none of them is utterly original. Still, Isherwood is able to describe each of them in a few lines with a very vivid touch, making the book a most enjoyable read.
Salvatore Cippico tells his life of Italian-Australian partisan from the early 20th century to the 90s. His ideas ground by History and his body crushed by the torturers, he ends up old and insane in a psychiatric hospital. One lost battle after the other, he tells his doctor how he was sent to Dachau because he was communist, and then to a concentration camp in Yugoslavia because he was on Stalin’s side when the alliance with Tito was broken. Of his love for figureheads and how they remember him of Maria, that he loved and abandoned when the Party asked him to do so. Of how once in his life he was among the torturers, too – when the communists slaughtered the anarchists during the civil war in Spain.
But his story has to be disentangled from his delirium, where he is also Jorgen Jorgensen, a Danish adventurer that was king of Islands for two weeks and prisoner for most of the rest of his life, and finally one of the chiefs of the extermination of the aboriginal Australians. And where he is also Jason, who brings back the golden Fleece reddened by the blood of his sailors and of his enemies; and many more.
The whole novel is written as the stream of consciousness of Cippico. Magris hides in it passages of great literature and reflections on the eternal war between the needs of History and those of individuals. It is hard not to be sucked into the vortex of the main character’s thoughts and their quick pace – this makes the book quite a difficult read. Take your time to linger over the most intense passages.
Tender Is the Night by F. Scott Fitzgerald
The rise and fall of Dick Diver: talented psychiatrist, renown scholar, brightest star at receptions in the French Cote Azur, social climber, drunkard, nullity. American by birth, Dick goes to Zurich to complete his studies in psychiatry. There he met Nicole: beautiful and outrageously rich, with a mental disorder that kept her in an asylum during her teen ages, preserving in her some kind of adolescent naiveness and purity. They marry and, as his career proceeds, they become regular on parties in the French Riviera. There, among spoiled youngsters and second-rate minds, his star shines brighter than ever. “Tender is the night” starts precisely at this moment – Dick Diver’s climax, and the beginning of his personal tragedy.
Like “The great Gatsby”, “Tender is the night” is the history of a man whose talent did not survive his friendships and passions, in a society where being shallow is the only antidote to a widespread corruption and dullness. Good people will be sooner or later punished for their sensitivity. Talented people will see the crowd cheer loudly at their fall. But while in “The great Gatsby” the driving force is love, in “Tender is the night” suffering has the leading role. Fitzgerald writes:
“One writes of scars healed, a loose parallel to the pathology of the skin, but there is no such thing in the life of individuals. There are open wounds, shrunk sometimes to the size of a pin-prick but wounds still. The marks of suffering are more comparable to the loss of a finger, or of the sight of an eye. We may not miss them, either, for one minute in a year, but if we should there is nothing to be done about it.”
The book is embellished by Fitzgerald’s style, that surfs between sharps descriptions and reflections of characters that are as insincere with the reader as they are with themselves. Among the fading lights of never-ending parties and the monotonicity of dream lives, Fitzgerald finds a narrow opening to teach us about the power of feelings and the harshness of life.
Discontent and Its Civilizations: Dispatches from Lahore, New York, and London by Mohsin Hamid
Collection of short essays on literature, Pakistan-related political and life issues.
The author has a peculiar life path – having extensively lived in the US, UK, and Pakistan. Articles on literature are average. Those where he strives to explain Pakistan to Westerns are more interesting, even if his ideas are not too original. In a couple of essays towards the ends, he summarizes and compares some political studies (by other authors) on Pakistan: those are probably the most relevant.
A Journey Round My Skull by Frigyes Karinthy
The Hungarian writer Frigyes Karinthy tells the story of his brain tumour, from the first symptoms to the successful surgical operation that led to its removal. The author reconstructs the events using his annotations from the period, enriching them with his humoristic style and the cheerfulness of someone who was able to survive such a terrible illness.
Everything starts with the annoying noise of some trains, that sounded real but were in fact only in the author’s head. It continues with smaller and bigger symptoms – headaches, view problems, vomiting – and wrong diagnosis. The most impressive symptom is probably the sense of detachment from reality that abruptly descends upon him one day, while sitting in a cafe: Why did he feel that this reality was, in fact, unreal? Was the mirror in front of him moving? Wasn’t everything else in the room rotating around the mirror?
As the tale goes on, we learn about the atmosphere of Hungarian cafes of the period – mid 1930s – and the intellectual life that animated them. About the high opinion that everybody (including himself) had of Karinthy, admired and loved with the passion that people nowadays reserve to popstars. His friends will find for him the best surgeon – a Swedish – and pay for the trip to Stockholm and the surgery. The passages on the removal of the tumour – done with the patient awake, but experiencing some kind of out-of-body experience – are among the most charming of the book.
This book is not just a precise description of the evolution of a tumour. It is the story of a self-confident, strong man losing everything and gaining unexpectedly everything again. It is told with humour and with a pleasant style, even if less brilliant than what I expected and I read in some other comments. This may be a fault of the translation (I read the Italian version).
Almost all critics I read hail this book as a masterpiece. I stopped roughly at 1/3, for two reasons. First, I did not like the fact that it starts right after a mysterious event, as a consequence of which Theo is hiding in Holland; and then, without explaining anything of this mysterious event, we are shipped back to Theo being 13. Television series are allowed those tricks to keep the viewer’s interest, literature should not be. Second, I found the description of Theo’s life with his mother and of the terrorists attacks to the Metropolitan Museum really average. One cannot say this part is badly written – it is not. But you can through it without almost feeling it: it does not teach us anything about a 13 years old boy’s life, fears, and love for his mother, that we did not know in advance. No brilliant line, no insight – and it’s more than 100 pages long.
A Mind at Play: How Claude Shannon Invented the Information Age by Jimmy Soni, Rob Goodman
Pros: brings to the attention of a broader public a central yet not so well known scientist from last century. Has a few curious anecdotal facts. Talks about maths, at moments.
Cons: shallow. Math could have been explained better and more in detail. There is no critical analysis of the events, just a huge mass of fact, each of which contributes to the depiction of Shannon more like a superhero from Marvel comics than a scientist. An hagiography more than a biography.
************************
Autobiografia di un baro by Luca Canali
Luca Canali è bello, intelligente, ambizioso. Giovane dirigente del PCI, donnaiolo, quindi brillante latinista, combatte in realtà tutta la vita con una sensazione di ineguatezza che lo fa sentire un impostore in ogni attività in cui gli altri lo guardano con ammirazione*. Nell’età matura svilupperà quindi una nevrosi ossessivo-compulsiva che gli renderà difficile ogni rapporto interpersonale, e complicherà anche il so lavoro. Corteggiato lungamente dalla morte, si spegnerà in realtà 30 anni dopo i fatti che racconta.
Luca Canali si confessa in modo amaro, senza scorciatoie nè pietismi. Leggendo “Autobiografia di un baro”, si avverte una stanchezza ed una rassegnazione alla sofferenza che lo fanno immaginare più vecchio di quanto in realtà fosse al momento della stesura (58 anni). La sua testimonianza è lucida ed appassionante, e solo per questo meriterebbe di essere letta. In più, ha una scrittura colta ed immaginifica, che salta agevolmente da questioni pubbliche a private e le lega insieme.
* Un aneddoto: il mio professore di italiano e latino del Liceo ha frequentato l’università contemporaneamente a Canali, di cui ci raccontava con una certa invidia il fascino ed il talento, che esercitava non solo sugli altri studenti, ma anche sui docenti.
Grande Raccordo by Marco Lodoli
Collezione di racconti con pregi e parecchi difetti.
Ciascuna storia è focalizzata su un personaggio differente, che spesso si racconta in prima persona, in una sorta di flusso di coscienza. Altre volte è seguito dall’autore passo passo nelle sue evoluzioni. Giovani o vecchi, uomini o donne, i protagonisti hanno quasi sempre lo stesso profilo: solitari, con uno sguardo talmente ingenuo sul mondo da risultare quasi demente, vivono spesso concentrati intorno ad un’unica passione, ignorando ed ignorati dal resto del mondo.
A mano a mano che si procede nella raccolta, questo monopersonaggio un po’ melenso risulta meno originale ed interessante, e di molti di questi racconti resta poco impresso, fatta forse eccezione per qualche descrizione un po’ suggestiva. A mio parere racconti come “Donna con Giardino” e “Esmeralda” non aggiungono niente al resto della raccolta.
Ce ne sono altri che risultano più freschi, dove il protagonista arriva ad essere più completo, meno macchietta. Uno dei migliori tra questi racconti è “Il mio amico Max”, anche se la storia ben creata dall’autore finisce nel luogo comune – l’attrazione per il mare (che è l’equivalente in termini narrativi del nome “San Marco” per una pizzeria). Mi sembra che questo sia un difetto comune a molti racconti. Un altro pezzo interessante (“Il settimo nano”) oscilla tra lo sguardo crudo à la Irvine Welsh ed un tentativo di realismo magico che termina nell’inverosimile (un ragazzino che per otto anni vive in cantina, e viene chiamato con tutti i nomi dei sette nani).
Mi sono invece sembrate più interessanti le descrizioni di due paginette ciascuna di situazioni e personaggi di tutti i giorni, che mi ricordano vagamente i Racconti Romani di Moravia. Bello anche il racconto che dà il titolo all raccolta, in cui verosibilmente Lodoli descrive se stesso (docente in un istituto professionale di periferia) e l’esperienza spersonalizzante del Grande Raccordo Anulare di Roma come metafora di vita.
Utopia e disincanto: Storie speranze illusioni del moderno: Saggi 1974-1998 by Claudio Magris
Dallo stile di Herman Hesse, ai saggi di Thomas Mann, all’identità dei popoli, agli eventi di cronaca quotidiana, sono raccolti in questo libro interventi di Magris su diversi temi, pubblicati soprattutto negli anni 90.
L’impronta degli articoli varia dalla riflessione colloquiale al saggio per esperti. Personalmente trovo il suo stile a tratti un po’ ridondante, sicuramente molto più vicino alla prosa tedesca che a quella anglosassone. Tutti gli scritti presentano interessanti spunti di riflessione, e Magris rafforza spesso le proprie opinioni con brillanti esempi, propri o di altri autori. Alle volte l’erudizione di Magris gli permette di entrare in dettagli e sottigliezze per me insignificanti, ed ho quindi lasciato alcuni articoli a metà. Ed altre volte non mi sono trovato d’accordo con le sue opinioni, fortemente influenzate da una visione progressista e cristiana del mondo. Ma non si può non ammirare la pacatezza, l’eleganza e la lucidità con cui Magris esprime il proprio pensiero.
Su tutti gli articoli spicca “Fuori i poeti dalla Repubblica?”, riflessione sul ruolo della letteratura nella società e nella vita di ognuno